|
But
lawyers for the companies told a panel of judges at
the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago that
the case is without merit and the corporations did nothing
to harm the current-day descendants.
``These
are inherently speculative claims,'' lawyer Owen Pell
said.
The
three-judge panel seemed to agree.
``If
you think you've been wronged, it shouldn't take 100
years to investigate the conduct of Aetna, Lehman Brothers
and the like,'' Circuit Judge Richard Posner said. ``There
are a lot of people living today whose parents were
wealthy in the 19th century who have nothing.''
The
case made its way to the appeals court after the lawsuit
was dismissed last summer by a federal judge, who said
the debate about reparations should be decided by the
legislative or executive branch.
If
the reparations advocates succeed, the companies will
have to account for the income they earned from slavery,
produce historical records and give up the profits earned
from slavery. The damage awards would be used to create
a court-supervised fund to help fix problems in the
black community.
Wednesday's
hearing comes at a pivotal time for the reparations
movement.
This
summer, the Moravian Church and the Episcopal Church
apologized for their roles in the slave trade and a
North Carolina commission urged the state to repay descendants
of a violent 1898 white supremacist campaign in Wilmington,
N.C.
And
corporations have begun to acknowledge their ties to
slavery, in part because of a series of state laws requiring
companies to do so. Several cities _ including Chicago,
Detroit and Oakland _ also have laws requiring businesses
to make such disclosures.
JP
Morgan Chase has acknowledged it owned 1,200 slaves
in Louisiana and accepted 13,000 others as collateral
before slavery was abolished in 1865.
Lawyers
pushing for the compensation said Wednesday the current
day ``market value'' of the company-owned slaves would
be at least $850 million.
The
company has since apologized for its role in slavery
and funded a $5 million college scholarship program
for black students from Louisiana. Company spokesman
Tom Kelly declined to comment on the litigation.
|